Justice and mercy are basically diametrically opposed, and God is both of them, apparently. That hidden conundrum is not exactly what this post is going to be about, but it is. I've decided the issue I'm thinking about traces back to this very distinction, and maybe it's just that I and most of my associates are young and relatively dumb yet, but none of us have been able to quite figure it out, whenever we really get into the dichotomy.
I will now do something that is nigh-impossible for me and, rather than delve into that fascinating tangent, stick to the topic at hand (despite the fact that I've yet to actually introduce said topic properly; here goes).
Upon reflecting and trying to lower my freaking defenses because I need to do a little spiritual calibration, which is another story, tonight...I was listening to some music and trying to coax my suppressed emotions out of the depths of their hibernation or whatever; "Wedding Dress" by Derek Webb was a pretty obvious choice, and as I was listening to it I was contemplating the imagery and the realities of (a) God's love, and (b) my idiocy. The blatant husband-wife comparison led my thoughts to the book of Hosea, and out of nowhere comes this mental image of me, as I sung along "I am a whore, I do confess..." and God replying, in some compassionate tone, "Don't call yourself that."
There's this constant tension in me between self-loathing and self-righteousness. Consequently, God—if I can even say such a thing—has got his work cut out for him. The full implication of the reply in my sudden mental image of dubious origin would have been something like... "no Heather, you're not a whore...it's not your fault; that is, not all your fault...to be sure, you're responsible for plenty by this time, but like most women who wind up living lives of ill-repute, you didn't choose this initially." Or that would be my best attempt at simplifying God's complicated, perfect-balance-between-justice-and-mercy response to the mess that is me; on the one hand, it's love and compassion and don't-worry-darling, but on the other there's a definite disappointed father (as though I of all people could mentally conjure a healthy version of that picture if my life depended on it) aspect, and I do have to in some sense (because well Jesus comes in at some point close to now) face what I've done and the matching fallout. It all makes my head spin.
Anyway, that information might be relevant; I started thinking, as I said, about Hosea. When I pictured God responding with pure compassion, as I also said, it was countered with the reminder that despite the (believe-it-or-not, appropriate) compassion, I was not (and never am) off the hook either. There's a book that's supposed to be a sort of retelling of Hosea, called Redeeming Love (by Francine Rivers). I read it in high school, and like every girl in high school, I certainly liked it quite a bit then, a fact which is nearly beside the point.
In the book, the girl who represents Gomer (people who name their daughter that are just asking for it, honestly) is totally a victim. The lines are clearly drawn; sweet innocent little girl who is essentially a miniature saint gets fucked over by the world—literally and figuratively. Handsome knight-in-shining-armor, whose last name just so happens to be Hosea, like the prophet (go figure) rides in on metaphorical steed to save the day. The lowering-of-her-defenses bit was relatively realistic. In the end, naturally, everything worked out.
The actual Bible story, if I remember, was a little less fairy-tale-esque, and the people involved in the drama were a far cry from these cherub-resembling characters of Rivers's. But maybe I'm being too cynical; who knows.
Everyone I know who's read Redeeming Love gushes about it to no end; but I haven't talked to anyone over the age of 25 who has read it, and all of them were women. In other words, their feedback is relatively worthless. It's either entirely emotional porn with Christianity sauce, or too close for comfort. In any event, I wonder if Francine Rivers focuses too much on mercy and too little on justice.
I wonder if I do.
This whole idea of needing spiritual calibration is from a combination of the books I've been reading as of late. Descent Into Hell and A Severe Mercy (which I finally had time to finish). I'm starting to get very uncomfortable with my sin, which unfortunately to my mind is inseperable with my utter inability to accept my general state of imperfection. But I do know that despite my best intentions, I'm afraid that as soon as I'm comfortable with the ideas of love and forgiveness, I'll sort of go prodigal knowing I'll be welcomed home again at the end. I'm terrified of that happening. I know myself too well to trust myself with any sort of quest for righteousness that involves freedom. What was God thinking when he gave me the ability to act as I pleased???
I guess at heart, I know that I don't really want God; or not as much as I should; I do, but I don't. There's this rebellious part of me. I suppose that would be what Paul called the flesh; then there's the spirit and this cognitive dissonance would be the constant battle between them, which he also speaks of at some length.
Either way, tonight as I waited for Nate and read my book, I was overcome by the impulse to prostrate myself on the floor of his apartment and pray for my salvation. I believe the responsible idea, which proverbially knocked the wind out of me, was in a letter from C.S. Lewis to Sheldon Vanauken (a frequent occurance among this book's pages), that Heaven and Hell are retroactive and they have to do with the overall state of a person's soul. Then I remembered that no soul can reach heaven by itself. Don't I claim to believe in Jesus and all that? So I don't want to forget or fall away or whatever, because then I never truly believed it at all. I guess I'm afraid "the flesh" will win out in me. I don't like it. I wish it would go away. But it's part of me, if it's what's being purged...I don't want to be holy. I want to have fun. And evidently the two are mutually exclusive. Even though I sometimes hate Paul, I really wish I could talk to Paul right now.
Well, this has been a very ADD post, hasn't it? I mostly just had to get these thoughts out, and they're still not organized. Please feel free to share any input.